| |
|
| |
|
|
by David Mitchell
In a word (or two or three): i bet the swan turns into some futuristic swami or something
From Mr. Hipster:
Ambition can sometimes get the best of
you. Thus is the fate of David Mitchell's second novel. Meant to be
a sort of metaphysical coming of age story, it turns into a weird
hodgepodge of mystery, sci-fi, Yakuza gangster and familial reconciliation.
Each of these parts could have been interesting on its own, but as
a comprehensive narrative only served to create a story full of cul-de-sacs.
It's as if Mitchell started off writing one novel and changed his
mind abruptly four or five times in the midst of typing. Even the
title's reference to the John Lennon song of the same name seems to
be a toss away in the book. Granted, our Japanese main character mentions
Yoko Ono on an occasional basis in a kind off-handed way, and owns
some of Lennon and Ono's music, but I'm not sure exactly what the
connection is. How anyone could listen to Yoko Ono is beyond me, and
may be some sort of inside joke that I'm not getting. The main plot
of the story revolves around Eiji, our 19-year-old protagonist, who
has moved from his small town in the sticks to Tokyo to find his biological
father, whom he has never known. His twin sister died when he was
younger and his mom is an estranged drunk who hasn't been around since
he was very young. His plan consists of staking out an office building
in which he believes his father's lawyer works. But inside his head
he's a futuristic super spy with gadgets and skillz he uses to infiltrate
the guarded building that houses his father's secret identity. Of
course the truth is that he's a fish out of water, a hick in the big
city with a minimum wage job and a cubbyhole apartment over a video
store. In his search for his father he runs into the powerful Yakuza
set, underground sex clubs and all sorts of other fun. It's not to
say the book isn't well written and entertaining to read, but it's
just so all over the place. Even our hero's fantasy world, such a
dynamic part of the beginning of the story, fades quickly and disappears
all together by the middle. Perhaps it's because his real life actually
becomes as bizarre as his dream world, vanquishing the need to imagine
being someone else. It's sort of clear what Mitchell is going for
in terms of an overarching idea, but it's all the stuff inside that
at times feels kind of forced or contrived to forward a point. In
fact there is a point where even one of the characters mentions all
of the coincidences that have happened to bring about the situation
in which Eiji ends up. So the individual pieces are well written and
engaging, but hanging together isn't their thing. It's almost as if
Mitchell, surprised by the success of his first novel, Ghostwritten,
thought it was a fluke and wanted to shove every idea he had in his
head into his follow-up just in case he was never allowed to publish
again. Mitchell is clearly in touch with the Japanese experience,
though, which is impressive in and off itself for a wacky Westerner
like him. I guess I could say I was disappointed after reading several
other of his books, but compared to most stuff I read this year, it's
still a fun treat of a novel.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
Black Swan Green
Cloud Atlas
Ghostwritten
|
|
| |
|
|
Home
| Booze & Grub | Movies
| Music | Books
| Diary
| Randomness
|
|
| |
|